BEATRICERSS button
introducing readers to writers since 1995

November 02, 2004

High-Low Demarcation Hits Queer Culture

by Ron Hogan

In collaboration with GLBTQ.com, Cleis Press has recently brought out The Queer Encyclopedia of the Visual Arts. It's just one in a series of books that collate (and, I imagine, add to) the information found about queer contributions to civilized culture you'll find on their encyclopedic website. Then there's Alyson's Mondohomo, "your essential guide to queer pop culture." This is more of a collection of articles on various themes interspersed with lists like "Top 10 Movies Every Queer (or Straight) Person Should See," which starts rather unpromisingly by going through the standard rigmarole (All About Eve, ho hum) but then just says to watch Citizen Kane and The Godfather because they're so damn good. Mind you, by "queer" this book pretty much means "gay," so all you lesbian pop culture mavens will have to go find your own book. Unfortunately, it's also got pretty much the most tasteless anecdote I've read all year; what starts out as a heartwarming tale about a group of guys who did an AIDS Ride in 2001 turns sour when Madonna decides to add a concert to her tour...

In a desperate bid to see their favorite diva in concert, Steve and his then-boyfriend scrambled to purchase tickets for the new show, even though it meant flying back a day early. The two of them boarded an American Airlines flight from Boston to Los Angeles on September 10th, instead of their original plan to fly back on American Airlines 11, on September 11th. Never forget: Madonna saves lives.

I propose that even camp has its limits, and making light of the deaths of 92 people (not to mention the victims in the north tower) to celebrate a past-her-prime singer more than surpasses those limits. What was no doubt intended as a darkly humorous sigh of relief comes across as simply callous. I'm sure all the victims' families hope Steve and his boyfriend enjoyed the concert very much, especially since it was postponed until later in the week.

Comments

Methinks, Beatrice, that you may lack a camp sensibility - best refrain from commenting on things you obviously don't understand.

Posted by: apricot at November 2, 2004 06:22 PM

Telling a guy who picked a girl's name for the website with which his identity is largely conflated that he lacks a camp sensibility seems, I dunno, a little misplaced, but I'm almost curious as to what exactly it is you think I don't understand about the moral frivolity, to borrow a phrase from Christopher Hitchens, exhibited by the author of that passage. There's whistling past the graveyard, and then there's callous insensitivity to other people's tragedy, and I think discerning readers can figure out into which of the two categories I feel the quoted material falls easily enough.

Posted by: editor at November 2, 2004 06:39 PM

Believe me, Ron doesn't exactly lack a camp sensibility. Take it from the person who knows best.

Posted by: The Significant Other at November 2, 2004 06:41 PM
If you enjoy this blog,
your PayPal donation
can contribute towards its ongoing publication.